5 Customers You Are Losing to Chewy Right Now (And How to Get Them Back)
You lost customers this month. Not because they were unhappy. Not because you did anything wrong. They left because someone else made it easier to stay. And the worst part? You probably did not notice any of them were gone.
Chewy does not steal your customers with a single dramatic move. They win them over quietly, one missed reorder at a time. Here are five types of customers who are slipping away from your store right now and what you can do to bring each one back.
The Monthly Food Buyer Who Forgot
This customer buys a premium 30-pound bag of dog food every 35 to 40 days. They have been coming in for over a year. But last month, life got busy. The bag ran low on a Tuesday night. Instead of driving to your store, they pulled up Chewy on their phone and set up auto-ship. The food arrived two days later. They have not thought about your store since.
How to get them back: Track reorder timing and send a reminder before they run out. If you know a customer buys food every 35 days, reach out on day 30. A simple text or email that says "Hey, your pup is probably getting low on food. We have a bag set aside for you" beats Chewy's algorithm every time. The key is timing. You have to reach them before they reach for their phone.
The Seasonal Buyer Who Drifted
Every spring, this customer came in for flea and tick prevention. They would grab a three-month supply, pick up some treats, and chat with your staff. This year, spring rolled around and they did not show up. A Chewy email reminded them first. They ordered from the couch and saved ten minutes of driving.
How to get them back: Reach out proactively before flea and tick season starts. In late February or early March, send a quick message to every customer who bought flea and tick products last year. Remind them the season is coming. Offer to set aside their usual brand. Being first to their inbox is the entire game with seasonal buyers.
The New Pet Parent Who Tried You Once
They walked in with a brand new puppy, excited and overwhelmed. They bought food, treats, a leash, and a toy. Spent $130 on their first visit. Your staff gave great recommendations. They said they would definitely be back. Then nobody followed up. No email. No text. No reason to remember your store name when the food ran out three weeks later.
How to get them back: Collect an email or phone number at the first visit and follow up within a week. A welcome message that says "Thanks for coming in with your new pup! Here are a few tips for the first month" builds a relationship that Chewy's warehouse never can. New pet parents are the highest value customers you will ever meet. Treat their first visit like the beginning of a relationship, not a one-time transaction.
The Loyal Customer Who Moved to Online
This customer has been shopping with you for years. They love your store. But between work, kids, and everything else, driving across town for dog food started to feel like a chore. Chewy's convenience finally won. Not because they stopped caring about your store. Because convenience is a powerful force and nobody gave them a reason to keep making the trip.
How to get them back: Offer something Chewy literally cannot. A small loyalty perk for in-store visits. A free sample of a new treat. A birthday card for their pet with a discount inside. Personal service, product expertise, and community are your competitive moat. Lean into them. Remind loyal customers why they started shopping local in the first place.
The Price Shopper Who Found a Deal
They were buying the same brand of treats from you every two weeks. Then one night they searched the product name on Google and found it three dollars cheaper on Chewy. That is all it took. Three dollars. They switched and have not looked back.
How to get them back: You do not need to win a price war on every product. Pick your top ten best sellers and make sure your pricing is competitive on those items. For everything else, emphasize the value that online retailers cannot match: your expertise, personalized recommendations, the ability to ask questions and get real answers, and the fact that every dollar they spend with you stays in the community.
The Bottom Line
None of these customers left because of a bad experience. They left because of a gap in communication. The food buyer forgot and nobody reminded them. The seasonal buyer drifted and nobody reached out. The new parent tried you once and nobody followed up. The loyal customer needed a reason to stay and nobody gave them one. The price shopper found a deal and nobody showed them the value.
The pattern is the same every time: silence. Your store went quiet at exactly the moment when a conversation could have kept them.
The good news is that most of these customers are not gone forever. They still live in your neighborhood. They still drive past your store. They still remember your name. You just need to reach out before Chewy makes them forget.
How Many Overdue Customers Does Your Store Have Right Now?
Take the free 60-second quiz and find out how many customers are past their reorder window and at risk of switching to Chewy.